RuneDev - The bot ripped from other bots

Printable View

Show 40 post(s) from this thread on one page

10-20-2010, 01:09 AM
sorcermus

Quote:

Originally Posted by pyroryan

Well I'm pretty sure tribot wasn't around back in June...Either way, I think its pretty clear that Tribot's scripteditor was used in production of runedev's scripteditor and hence should be credited.

I have indeed already offered credit.
10-20-2010, 01:15 AM
pyroryan

Quote:

Originally Posted by sorcermus

I have indeed already offered credit.

I have no issues against modifying open-source code as long as the new code is properly credited.
I don't think anyone is trying to bring down your development team, but having an uncredited and seemingly copied piece of work looks very bad on this site and makes me suspicious of the entire group.
10-20-2010, 01:23 AM
sorcermus

Quote:

Originally Posted by pyroryan

I have no issues against modifying open-source code as long as the new code is properly credited.
I don't think anyone is trying to bring down your development team, but having an uncredited and seemingly copied piece of work looks very bad on this site and makes me suspicious of the entire group.

credit was never asked of Runedev. Just removal of what we have.
10-20-2010, 01:24 AM
Putnam

If you seriously want this project to go anywhere, you may as well write the code, and review what others give you. It doesn't look like you wrote 40% of the code, maybe modified 10%.
If anyone of your members in your userbase found out you use other's code, what would they think of you?

EDIT: Also, implying that we were some of your former members of your development team shows how much you care about this. Shouldn't you know who has worked for you? Seems pretty professional to me.
10-20-2010, 01:29 AM
sorcermus

Quote:

Originally Posted by putnam11

Also, if you seriously want this project to go anywhere, you may as well write the code and review what others give you. It doesn't look like you wrote 40% of the code, maybe modified 10%.
If anyone of your members in your userbase found out you use other's code, what would they think of you?

on this note I'm out of here. I have nothing more to say here.
10-20-2010, 01:38 AM
moparisthebest

As long as all of this code is GNU/GPL then I don't see any problem with what anyone did, besides the fact that it is nice to give credit where credit is due. Otherwise, code-reuse (as opposed to re-inventing the wheel) is what Open Source code is all about!
10-20-2010, 01:49 AM
TRiLeZ

Quote:

Originally Posted by pyroryan

Well I'm pretty sure tribot wasn't around back in June...Either way, I think its pretty clear that Tribot's scripteditor was used in production of runedev's scripteditor and hence should be credited.

TRiBot went public Feb 7, 2010 and the script editor was made on Feb 16, 2010.

Quote:

Originally Posted by sorcermus

I am the only developer of the Runedev client at this time and I am not removing code that 30 percent comes from a demo 30 percent comes from others and 40 percent comes from me. Anyone else could write from the demos of the highlight package and tribot would have nothing to be able to say the package and the denmo were free.

IceXaos is not the owner of the client just the site.

For the record Runedev has its shit together now and asking us to take something out that was worked on a group development simply becuase some one wants to right protect it now after the fact is insane. Thats like a developer of google asking that google change everything they have just becuase someone wants to right protect some part of it now. Near as I can tell who ever did whatever didn't do it at a time that anyone was trying to right protect it, and even if they tried they couldn't for the free open source that is in it. So it is a mute point.

Then again you and the other guy trolling this topic are more than likely 2 of the guys that got kicked to the road side because thats all thsoe guys did, and you guys seem hell bent on trying to make the Runedev development tean that we have now look bad. You just can't I haven't done anything and Im not ripping things out.

So, it's 70% from the Runedev team? So is the syntax highlighter just an addition to a massive piece of Runedev coding? The script editor revolves around the syntax highlighter.

With your google scenario... if I were appart of the Runedev dev team, it would be like that scenario, but I'm not. My script editor was not made for Runedev. It was made JUST for TRiBot.

Here's a better scenario: It's like you stole a piece of merchandise and got caught, and you're not returning the merchandise. It's theft.

Quote:

Originally Posted by sorcermus

I have indeed already offered credit.

Quote:

Originally Posted by sorcermus

credit was never asked of Runedev. Just removal of what we have.

Did I not say, somewhere in my posts in this thread or the one at my forums that I would have been fine is I was credited?

If you can give me credit, in the script editor coding/about box and somewhere on the Runedev website or forums, then I'll agree to put this issue to rest.
10-22-2010, 12:46 AM
Camaro'

Quote:

Originally Posted by moparisthebest

As long as all of this code is GNU/GPL then I don't see any problem with what anyone did, besides the fact that it is nice to give credit where credit is due. Otherwise, code-reuse (as opposed to re-inventing the wheel) is what Open Source code is all about!

Apparently what I gather, is that he is claiming the code his own, which I don't think is allowed :)

Edit: Me r dumb

Show 40 post(s) from this thread on one page