Used to be i always play with my Xbox original and enjoyed ol games like Fable and Halo 2 (But i hardly played after 2 years till now). I got my Xbox 360 late November.
First game i got was Halo Reach, and everything here changed for me. With new abilities, weapons, veichles and just about everything from Halo 2. I was pleased with the game and got hooked with multiplayer! And comming from a guy who used to frequently play Halo 2, Halo Reach is just GOD LIKE.
Second game was Fable 3, and as much as it's great on graphics and gameplay, the story was way too short especially the time to rule as a king (or queen) and i collected all the silver keys and gold keys and unlocked some bad ass weapons. It's clear to me that even as Fable 3 dominates, obviously through grahpics, Fable and Fable TLC (for PC) was just better to me.
My third game, im having some debate over my head over which should be my next game. I never really lept away from my most 2 favorite games.
So the list goes...
1. Mass Effect 2
2. Red Dead Redemption
3. Oblivion IV Elder Scrolls
4. Assasins Creed Brotherhood (I beat AC, never bought AC2 so i have no idea what just happened afterwards).
Those 4 games i looked over review after reviews. So far im leaning to the first one i picked Mass Effect 2 as it holds many promising stuff.
Im going to buy all these games at one point anyways :P I just buy a game, beat it and make sure i finish everything (Im a completionist :P) So itll take time to buy all of them. Especially if i get Oblivion as i head it sucks the life out of you.
So post what i should get and why! Thanks
Also i quit Runescape after botting for soo long.
I got 13 level 99s, CB is 136 and total wealth is 270M. Its been a long ride (Ive been in SRL for atleast 3-4 years i guess) and i played runescape for 7 years. Never been banned, because the bots here are just too human like for Jagex to catch on. But than i bought some bots and ya. Been absent here for a while.
















also you should try fall out, other then that i have not played the games on your list 



they where a let down, and get fall out 3 its good, although i played new vegas round a friends and did not like it much




